
Hollywood Gnosticism Decoded
Revelation of the Method, the Master Manipulator, and the Dark Self
Part 3: The Torture and Death of the Soul
By Dr. Brett Carollo
November 2026
Bane: Your punishment must be more severe.
Bruce: Torture?
Bane: Yes. But not of your body. Of your soul.
–Dark Knight Rises (2012)
The Gnostic Toxin
Inception, Dark City
The spiral that Det. Walenski manically scribbles everywhere, in Dark City, is an apt symbol for the bottomless spiral of inversions (and recursions) inherent to the Method. Walenski stands for the compulsive truth-seeker, whose quest for truth is weaponized against him, so that he can’t stop “thinking in circles” and, at length driven to the ineluctable conclusion that “there’s no way out,” jumps in front of a train. Likewise, for those who swallow Hollywood’s Luciferian red pill, their own “desire to return to reality” is transformed into a potentially fatal psychic poison

A bottomless spiral of inversions (Dark City)
That malicious devices like red pill programming, wielded by cinematic demiurges, are capable of, and frequently aimed at, nothing less than the torture and death of the viewer’s soul is revealed quite strikingly in Inception. Cobb, we slowly learn, had a wife named Mal (Marion Cotillard) with whom he was once trapped in “limbo,” the depths of the unconscious, for what seemed like a lifetime. Mal having abandoned herself to the limbo dream, losing all sense of the distinction between dream and reality, Cobb “planted an idea” in her mind to get her to wake up, namely, the idea “that her world wasn’t real.” Breaking into that “secret place” in the “deepest recess of her mind,” pictured as a safe within a doll house within a house (more boxes within boxes), Cobb gained access to Mal’s core self, represented by a small metal top that was her “totem”—an object relied on by dreamers to distinguish the dream state from reality. By manipulating this object (it spins indefinitely in the dream state), he simultaneously manipulated her entire perception of reality, such that he convinced her to commit dream suicide with him in order to wake up. The spell was so powerful, in fact, that after resurfacing from limbo, Mal remained “possessed” by this “very simple idea.” Concluding, like Walenski in Dark City, that “death was the only escape,” she eventually committed suicide in earnest, framing him for murder so that he might join her on the journey “home.” Here is Revelation of the Method at its most sinister: the very idea that Nolan himself places at the center of Inception and of the late 90s gnostic films that inspired it, the idea that Inception is in fact incepting in its audience—this idea, that one’s present reality is merely a simulation or a dream, is shown within the diegesis of the film itself to be an extreme info hazard, a psychic toxin that, in large enough doses, commonly induces a desire to kill oneself and possibly everyone else too.


Boxes within boxes (Inception)
Any doubt that Inception is purveying this deadly toxin, i.e., that it is attempting to produce in the audience something akin to the state of ontological disorientation that drives Mal to suicide, is put to rest by the final frames. Apparently returning home, his name cleared, Cobb spins Mal’s top on the table to assure himself that he’s not still nested in the dream world. But he immediately abandons it to embrace his children, willing to accept this happy ending world whether fake or not. Nolan’s camera lingers on the spinning top for several beats, teasing the audience, then cuts to black an instant before the totem pronounces its verdict—which has the effect, on the one hand, of freezing/perpetuating the ontological disorientation the entire film has labored to imbue in the audience and, on the other hand, of reinforcing this state by suggesting that the distinction between dreaming and waking, illusion and reality, does not matter and that one should therefore embrace the pleasing fictions concocted by the world-builders. It’s crucial, in terms of the Revelation of the Method, that this self-serving, pseudo-subliminal messaging, directed at the audience, is encoded in the same object used by Cobb which drove his wife to suicide: for Nolan is doing to the soul of the viewer what Cobb did to his wife, Mal being a typical Nolan anima figure, symbol of the soul, here transformed into the femme fatale nemesis (“Mal” is Latin for bad or evil) of the guilt-stricken master manipulator.


Left to right: Mal goes mad / Locking the viewer’s ontological disorientation (last frames of Inception)
“Tampering with the Soul”: Archetypal World-Building as Mass Mind Control
Dark City, Batman Begins (2005), Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016), Watchmen (2009)
It’s crucial too, of course, that Inception constantly reminds its audience that people in this derealized state are extraordinarily suggestible and hence eminently susceptible to having their inner worlds rebuilt for them by accomplished master manipulators like Nolan. And it’s significant that Cobb is not a true artist but a hired gun, since the master manipulator, even more so than the auteur, is in truth the manipulated manipulator, at the service of the industry and the forces—economic, political, and spiritual—that rule over it. (Themes of guilt and blackmail running through his early filmography, especially Insomnia and the last two Batman films, hint at Nolan’s own predicament.) It’s probably not necessary anymore to insist on the prodigious power of mass media in general and cinema more specifically to engineer values, opinions, habits, and so forth. Inception and the gnostic films that inspired it are actually recursive depictions of cultural engineering, and thus it is remarkable, for more than one reason, that they portray the engineering of the mass mind as more or less directly analogous to the trauma-based mind control of individuals.
First, the deliberate exaggeration-by-analogy is a power technique: insofar as the viewer internalizes the basic gnostic conceit that the world is a managed simulation, his mind acquiesces to the inevitability that culture and society will be so managed by those who wield the technology to control the means of perception. To the extent that these fictional scenarios are modeled on the real aspirations of contemporary tech wizards (e.g., the VR-gaming tech of Existenz and Thirteenth Floor, premised on brain-computer interfaces), we may say that they illustrate the role that predictive programming plays in the Revelation of the Method. This power technique also instantiates the principle which Michael Aquino, in a now infamous US Army “concept paper,” makes the cornerstone of successful psychological warfare, i.e., that victory in “MindWar”—the neologism, inspired by Star Wars, Aquino says should replace the term “psychological operations”—is achieved via the “deliberate, aggressive convincing of all participants in a war that we will win that war.”1 In other words, one achieves power by projecting it, or one succeeds by convincing everyone, including oneself, of the inevitability of success.

Col. Michael Aquino
Like Revelation of the Method as a whole, the above is fundamentally an occult technique, one with which Aquino was well acquainted as an accomplished Satanist and the founder of the Temple of Set. Around the same time he was composing “From PSYOP to MindWar: The Psychology of Victory,” Aquino, as many readers are aware, faced accusations that he and his wife were experimenting on or programming children at the Presidio base in San Francisco employing SRA (Satanic ritual abuse) techniques. Many of these children accurately described the inside of his home and knew his and his wife’s nicknames, apart from many other pieces of corroborating evidence. Aquino has published his own “parodies” of the Star Wars trilogy, which some Monarch conspiracy authors claim are used as mind control programming scripts. At any rate, Aquino’s entire career, such as we know of it, encapsulates the shadowy historical relationship between trauma-based mind control, the occult, and the sort of mass media psyops alluded to throughout these gnostic films (not to mention many other post-Vietnam productions related to mind control). And even if the broader picture of post-MKUltra mind control operations remains obscure, these films, by virtue of performing Revelation of the Method, also genuinely reveal something of this relationship, that is, of how cybernetic techniques of individual or micro mind control contributed to the development of mass or macro mind control techniques (and vice-versa), mediated by occult principles.


Microcosmic mazes (Dark City)
Once again, Dark City stands out among its gnostic contemporaries in how clearly it likens demiurgic world-building to mass mind control experimentation. Dr. Schreber is introduced to us hovering over a giant circular maze populated by lab mice—a microcosm of the Strangers’ predatory experiment, which in turn is a microcosm of the Method looped back to the viewer. The maze-like moving spiral which is the film’s main visual motif and which dominated its marketing is of course a recognized symbol of hypnosis and therewith of hypnotic mind control. The Strangers’ psi abilities include the power to hypnotically induce sleep at an instant, and all of the memory programming occurs after the city has been put to sleep, evoking the “deep sleep treatments” developed by the mad Dr. William Sargant, advisor to MKUltra maniac Dr. Ewen Cameron. Even the central plot conceit, that it’s possible to refashion memories, however seemingly far-fetched, also draws on a real area of MKUltra research. Dr. Louis Jolyon West, who reported directly to MKUltra chief Sidney Gottlieb, informed his superiors, as early as 1956, that he could replace “true memories” with “false ones.” As Tom O’Neill, who discovered this little bombshell in West’s papers at UCLA, reports, West said he accomplished this feat “by administering ‘new drugs’ effective in ‘speeding the induction of the hypnotic state and in deepening the trance that can be produced in given subjects.’” O’Neill also unearthed a letter in which West is complaining to Gottlieb about a Major Robert Williams, who was hindering West’s experiments at Lackland Air Force Base on the grounds that they amounted to “tampering with the soul.”2

Top: Dr. William Sargant
Bottom: Dr. Jolyon “Jolly” West

The subject is close to Nolan’s heart, as we’ve seen, and thus it’s not surprising to find a direct reference to MK-superstar Jolly West in Batman Begins (2005), when Dr. Crane (Cilian Murphy), chief psychiatrist at Arkham Asylum, enters mob moss Falcone’s (Tom Wilkinson) cell and drives him instantly insane through the combination of an aerosolized, terror-inducing drug and a scarecrow mask. The scene is alluding to Jack Ruby, likewise a man of the criminal underworld with no prior history of mental illness, becoming permanently insane immediately following a special visit to his cell from none other than West, who happened to be a specialist in inducing the dissociative, fragmented mental states at the foundation of trauma-based mind control—and who would pay similar visits, at the behest of the government, to Patty Hearst and Timothy McVeigh, among other high-profile criminal defendants who were certainly or likely subjected to mind control.


Left to right: Dr. Crane plays Jolly West to Falcone’s Jack Ruby (Batman Begins)
When assistant DA Rachel (Katie Holmes) confronts Crane, questioning why Falcone’s sudden madness happens to revolve around the figure of the scarecrow, the doctor replies with a very telling piece of misdirection. “Patients suffering delusional episodes,” he explains, “often focus their paranoia on an external tormentor, usually one conforming to Jungian archetypes—in this case, a scarecrow.” While this deceptive answer has the effect of reducing conspiracy to psychology, the invocation of Jungian archetypes, by a psychiatric villain modeled in part on an infamous MKUltra maniac, also hints at the hidden role that depth psychology has played both in trauma-based mind control and in cinematic world-building. Analytical psychology, as Jung referred to his system, has been deeply entangled with the American intel establishment since well before MKUltra or even the CIA. Jung himself carried on a warm correspondence with Allen Dulles, the two having first met in 1936. During the war, Jung served the OSS (precursor to the CIA) as a psychological consultant (agent 488), with Dulles’s mistress, Mary Bancroft, being a key intermediary between the two men. Bancroft was not only Jung’s patient but also a fervent promoter of Jungianism in America. Likewise, Dulles’s daughter, after graduating from the C.G. Jung Institute, went on to be a notable American Jungian.3 And it goes on and on. The key connection between Jungianism and mind control, micro and macro, consists in the fact that both the mind control programmer and the master manipulator rely on the theory of archetypes in one form or another, including Campbell’s monomyth, insofar as their targets actually project the contents of their psyches onto the characters and narratives designed to represent the archetypes. Thus captured, these contents can, in theory, be “deconstructed” and rearranged into new mental patterns.
In the post-cinema era, where entertainment is defined by deeper and deeper levels of immersion/dissociation into more and more elaborate worlds, the Marvel and DC superhero franchises have been the most conspicuous sites of these exercises in reengineering the mass mind via archetypal world-building. As synchromystic Christopher Knowles observed, just before superhero-mania took hold at the box office, “superheroes now play for us the role once played by the gods in ancient societies.”4 As such they perform the same archetypal function, capturing the same psychic projections of those who are successfully entrained by the narratives. For decades now, the industry has endlessly deconstructed and reconstructed these spandex gods in a frequently transparent campaign to advance a variety of New World Order cultural, political, and especially religious agendas.
That these projects, at their most ambitious, are engaging in religious engineering is confirmed by Zack Snyder, director of many a mega-budgeted superhero movie. His 2009 adaptation of Watchmen, like the Alan Moore comic, is meant, he says, as a “challenge” to “your icons, your morality, how you perceive pop culture, how you perceive mythology, and for that matter, how you perceive God.” The master manipulator’s success in these ambitions, Snyder reminds us, is a direct function of the extent to which he successfully blurs fantasy and reality. In something of a departure from virtually all previous comic book cinema, Watchmen endeavors to blend its superheroes—stand-ins for the gods and hence containers for the audience’s archetypal projections—into an otherwise recognizable historical setting. Thus, in keeping with the comic, the film “almost superimposes its heroes on your world, which then changes how you view your world through its prism.”5

Superheroes Spirituality
Much the same verisimilitude technique is on display in Snyder’s Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016). Loaded with religious tropes, Batman v Superman is a still more ambitious exercise in religious engineering, highlighted by a heavy-handed deconstruction of God the Father through the Superman character. Lex Luthor (Jesse Eisenberg) here is a neo-gnostic villain, obsessed with the relationship between knowledge and power, who identifies himself as “the devil” and whose master plan is to pit “man” (Batman) against “God” (Superman) in order to “kill God.” Luthor is defeated, but Superman (Henry Cavill) dies in the process, making way for a wholesale reconfiguration of the archetype. Note too, as Millary has pointed out to me, that Luthor here represents the Promethean tech-gnosticism of the transhumanist broligarchs, which is being similarly deconstructed in favor of the Luciferian gnosticism of the Hollywood superclass. In effect, Snyder uses Luthor as a tool to break down the audience’s already warped God image, which he begins reconstructing in anticipation of the sequel, Justice League (2017).
For the latter, Snyder designed a t-shirt logo featuring the Kabbalistic tree of life with Justice League superhero symbols as sephirah. The culminating image, directly opposite the Superman logo at the top of the design, is an infant, which represents the child of Superman and Lois Lane whose birth Snyder intended to form the conclusion of the unfinished series. This is none other than the Crowleyan “divine child,” a human-god/material-spiritual hybrid, born of mortal woman, whose appearance is to usher in the Age of Horus—and whose purpose is to supplant the Christ child with a type of Satan. The same “divine child” archetype is the basis of the Star Child of 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968), the Antichrist child of Rosemary’s Baby and a swarm of knockoffs and spinoffs, the superpowered “gifted child” of Monarch cinema, and of a host of other productions great and small touched by the Crowleyization of Hollywood.6
“Torture the Women”: Filmmaking as Murder
The Prestige (2006), Peeping Tom (1960), Goodfellas (1990), Psycho (1960), Strange Days (1995), White of the Eye (1987)
To repeat, man is created in the image of God, and therefore the destruction of the image of God amounts to the death of the soul. In Jungian terms, the primary female figure, in dreams or in fiction (understood as collective dreams), is the anima, or soul image. Particularly in Nolan’s earlier films, the women closest to the protagonists very often meet a bad end, as with Mal in Inception and the wife in Memento, leaving the heroes mentally shattered in one way or another. The death of the soul, including the soul of the artist, is in fact a leitmotif in Nolan’s work. The first act of The Prestige (2006), for example, culminates with the on-stage death of a woman named Julia (Piper Perabo), wife of stage magician Angier (Hugh Jackman), who thereafter descends into an increasingly soulless pursuit of professional success at all costs, discarding another love interest/magical helper/anima figure (Scarlett Johansson) along the way. Meanwhile, Sarah (Rebecca Hall), the wife of rival magician Borden (Christian Bale), hangs herself. The film as a whole is a masterpiece in Revelation of the Method in which magic real and staged represents the filmmaking process. Reflecting the development of the Method, particularly in the wake of MKUltra and the Phoenix Program, Angier pursues a truly scientific form of magic, acquiring a machine from Nikola Tesla (David Bowie) with which he generates clones of himself to be sacrificed during each performance, drowned in a water tank like Julia. In the end, Angier can’t be sure that he isn’t a clone.

Butterfly=soul=actress (The Prestige)
The butterfly hairpin worn by Julia just before she drowns further identifies her as an anima figure, the butterfly being a traditional symbol of the soul. As the magicians’ female assistant, she also represents the leading lady in a film production. The same isomorphic parallel implicated here—between the lead actress, her character, and the audience itself—is captured best by proto-master manipulator Alfred Hitchock’s formula for handling actresses: “I always believe in following the advice of the playwright Sardou: ‘Torture the women.’. . . The trouble today is that we don’t torture the women enough.” As noted by Jasun Horsley, who highlights this remark in 16 Maps of Hell: The Unraveling of Hollywood Superculture (2019), “Hitchcock was known to torture his actresses off-screen as well as on.”7


Nolan tortures the women (The Prestige, Memento)
At its most “scientific,” the off-screen torture of the stars is synonymous with mind control, dating back to Marilyn Monroe and the model Candy Jones. In a 2022 Instagram post, Britney Spears described being drugged, physically humiliated, and forced to undergo endless hours of so-called psychiatric treatment per her court-mandated conservatorship. Accompanying the post was a visual cryptogram which, when decoded, translates into the letters “CIA.”8 Apart from the extensive relationship, official and unofficial, between Hollywood and the federal government, including the intel agencies, there are many pieces of evidence for the continuity of deep state mind control and the management of what Millary calls IMSAs, or Illuminati mind slave artists. When Kanye West went off the reservation in 2022, he tweeted a screenshot of a text message from his personal trainer, Harley Pasternak, threatening to have Ye “institutionalized again where they medicate the crap out of you, and you go back to Zombieland forever. Play date with the kids just won’t be the same.”9 What makes this sinister threat yet more sinister is that Pasternak, whose client list is a Who’s Who of A-listers and IMSAs (e.g., Halle Berry, Lady Gaga, Katy Perry, and Megan Fox), had previously conducted drug experiments for the same branch of the Canadian military that funded the Canadian wing of MKUltra, led by the psychopathic Dr. Cameron.10

Screenshot of Spears’ Instagram post (now deleted)
Cameron, incidentally, was assisted by Dr. James Tyhurst, later convicted for sexually enslaving and torturing four of his female patients. Similarly, MK-psychiatrist William Joseph Bryan—who was a consultant on The Manchurian Candidate (1962) as well as on Francis Ford Coppola’s directorial debut, Dementia 13 (1963), and who may well have hypnotized alleged RFK assassin Sirhan Sirhan—got a slap on the wrist from the California medical board for hypnotizing and sexually abusing female patients. The audience too is a woman, as Gustav Le Bon and Adolf Hitler well appreciated, and thus the scientific torture of the actress—off screen and on, real and fictional—is also the scientific torture of the viewer’s soul.
The horror genre, of course, is most notorious for vicariously torturing the audience through the women. One may call it Hollywood’s laboratory of torture. In the same way that heavy metal externalized the Satanic influence that pervades the music industry at large, horror movies lay bare, in the most jarring and undisguised fashion, the malicious techniques of audience manipulation that characterize master manipulator filmmaking in general. As Martin Scorsese once remarked, “If you don’t really understand or appreciate the horror film, the horror genre, you really have no understanding or love of film itself.” It’s a “very inside thing,” he adds.11 The familiar trope of a sharp object piercing the eye (window to the soul), featured on countless horror movie posters, signifies, in the most concise fashion, the psychic destruction of the viewer to which the master manipulator aspires. The “eye scream,” as it has been called, dates back as far as the late silent era and Luis Buñuel’s seminal surrealist film Un Chien Andalou (1929), which begins with a man slicing a woman’s eye open with a razor. The ubiquitous one-eye sign—which saturates celebrity photo shoots, movie poster art, music videos, etc.—is basically another variation on the same trope. At one level, it marks the celebrity bearing it as an initiate into traumatic occult mysteries and hence an industry slave. In this way, the one-eye sign encapsulates the cyclical dynamic wherein the traumatization of performers feeds into the (lower-intensity) traumatization of the audience, both thereby enthralled to the industry.

Un Chien Andalou
A certain variation on the trope, as Horsley notes, goes back still further, nearly to the birth of moving pictures, that is, a gun pointed and fired directly into the camera/at the audience, first appearing in the last frames of Edwin Porter’s The Great Train Robbery (1903). “From its original moments,” writes Horsley, “cinema was designed as a blow to the retina that broke through to the brain: an intrinsically aggressive, assaulting, and violent medium.” The “basic image of a character firing a gun towards the camera,” he continues, “has been repeated countless times.” It is especially prominent in films with strong overtones of mind control and psychological warfare, e.g., The Manchurian Candidate and Scorsese’s Taxi Driver (1976).


Left to right: The Manchurian Candidate, Taxi Driver
As Horsley notes, in “The Moviegoer” (his contribution to CES 1), a particularly telling instantiation of the trope appears in the final frames of Scorsese’s Goodfellas,
when Tommy is briefly resurrected for a “last shot” at the audience. This leads to the closing credits song, “My Way,” as performed by Sid Vicious. During his performance of the song in The Great Rock ‘n’ Roll Swindle mockumentary, Vicious unloads a pistol into the bourgeois audience before leaving the stage in disgust.12

Tommy’s last bang (Goodfellas)
The double reference, to The Great Train Robbery and the Sid Vicious music video, is to be taken in context of the immediately preceding cut, in which Henry (Ray Liotta) laments that he is doomed to be “an average nobody,” a “schnook.” In other words, Henry, forced to enter the Witness Protection program, is doomed to be just like you there staring at the screen—and most unlike the freewheeling psychopathic Tommy (Joe Pesci), embodiment of the criminal lifestyle that the film unabashedly romanticizes. By “resurrecting” the dead Tommy in the final frames, Scorsese means to simultaneously glorify the spirit of liberated transgression his character represents and to assert the nearly godlike status of the filmmaker as the higher expression of this type, capable, like a horror movie monster, of overcoming death to torment audiences forever. In this moment, the curtain is pulled back to reveal the filmmaker’s secret bond with the dark self—and with the devil.
Around 2010, I attended a screening of Goodfellas at the Dryden Theater in Rochester, NY, which is directly adjacent to the Eastman House film archive where Scorsese stores the bulk of his private film collection. Introducing the picture, Jim Healy, the Assistant Curator at the time, made an observation that has stayed with me ever since, as my view of Scorsese has darkened over time. “If,” I remember him saying, “Scorsese’s previous effort,” i.e., The Last Temptation of Christ (1988), “was about Christ, this is a film about the devil.” Healy was referring to Scorsese’s intoxicatingly effective and totally unrepentant celebration of criminality through the perspective of one of his favorite character types, that is, the unrepentant sinner, the Goodfellas version of which (Henry) is memorably reprised in the Jordan Belfort character (Leonardo DiCaprio) in The Wolf of Street. Goodfellas is not a Revelation of the Method film per se, but the ending is certainly a Revelation of the Method moment, in which the fourth wall is broken to show the audience—and to assault them with—the hidden thread of psychopathology that connects the entertainment industry to the criminal underworld.
Carried to the extreme (such is the nature of transgression), this thread of psychopathology leads, in Horsley’s words, to “the equivalency of filmmaking with murder” or “the director as murderer.”13 Most ominously, the merging of master manipulator filmmaking with the psychopathological embrace of transgression produces the director as psycho-sadistic serial killer, heralded by Hitchcock’s Psycho (1960). For, as Carol Clover explains, Hitchcock’s “marginal jottings in the shooting instructions for the shower scene” demonstrate how he “explicitly located thrill in the equation victim = audience.”14
The equation of audience with victim and director with psycho-sadistic serial killer comes out even more explicitly in another 1960 proto-slasher film by a different British director, that is, Michael Powell’s Peeping Tom, which happens to be one of Scorsese’s favorite films. It also happens to be written by one of Britain’s leading cryptographers during WWII, Leo Marks, whom Scorsese cast as the voice of Satan in Last Temptation of Christ. (Incidentally, De Niro has said that his own rendition of Satan, in 1987’s Angel Heart, was modeled on Scorsese.) “Even more than Psycho,” writes Horsley, “more in fact than any other horror film ever made, Peeping Tom (1960) is all about cinema.” Taking “the ‘camera as weapon’ metaphor to literal extremes,” it’s about a photographer named Mark (Carl Boehm) who murders women with a steel spike fastened to a camera, filming their deaths.15 As a child, he was constantly filmed and subjected to traumatizing experiments by his father (played by Powell himself), a psychiatrist studying fear in children. Now Mark forces his victims to witness their own deaths on a mirror attached to the tripod. As another psychiatrist says of him, “He has his father’s eyes.”

The same trope, of a killer forcing victims to witness their deaths through the killer’s eyes, occurs in several other more or less recursive films engaging in some degree of Revelation of the Method. It is central, for example, to Kathryn Bigelow’s Strange Days (1995), co-written by her then-husband James Cameron. Instead of a mirror, the killer uses a technology, which in the film’s near-future setting has largely supplanted movies as an entertainment medium, that records and plays back experiences. The trope is also central to White of the Eye (1987), a somewhat obscure serial killer film (with intimations of sonic-induced mind control) directed by Donald Cammell, who, as we’ve seen, is one of the alpha channels for the spread of Crowleyism in Hollywood. In each case, translating victim=audience, the cinematic murder of the viewer’s soul is equated with the transfer of the killer-director’s pathology to the viewer, such that, in Horsley’s words, his “eyes then become the eyes of the audience.”16 Insofar as the director seeks the total moral corruption of the audience through the recursive depiction of his own or the industry’s total moral corruption—say, by glorifying and romanticizing criminal psychopaths—this type of cinema is performing a radically sinister form of Revelation of the Method: destroying the viewer’s soul by forcing him to witness its destruction.
The Taking of the Eyes: Revelation of the Method as Torture of the Soul
Anguish (1987)
Thus, in forcing viewers to see through his own eyes, the filmmaker is really taking their eyes, i.e., their souls. And this trope too, of the killer taking the eyes of his victims, occurs in a stunningly blatant Revelation of the Method slasher film from 1987, titled Anguish. The main character, John (Michael Lerner), is an overweight, middle-aged ophthalmologist with failing eyesight. His only companion is his mother (Zelda Rubinstein), a powerful psychic who hypnotically programs him to commit serial murder and to bring her the victims’ eyes, which he removes with a scalpel. About twenty minutes in, the primary narrative is revealed to be a meta-movie, a movie-within-a-movie, which is playing inside a movie theater called The Rex. As the patrons of The Rex watch “The Mommy,” many grow increasingly anxious and agitated, with one girl in particular, credited as “Patty,” verging on psychological breakdown. “I don’t want to see this,” she pleads with her friend. “It’s making me sick. I want to leave.” In the release cut of Anguish, a pre-credit “disclaimer” informed theatrical audiences that they were in for the same treatment: “During the film you are about to see, you will be subject to subliminal messages and mild hypnosis. This will cause you no physical harm or lasting effect, but if for any reason you lose control or feel that your mind is leaving your body—leave the auditorium immediately.” Accompanying narration mentioned free medical services available in the lobby and instructed moviegoers to stay vigilant and keep to themselves, hinting that copycat killers may lurk among them.



The pseudo-warning is pure red pill programming, intended to keep audiences in their seats and to render them still more susceptible to the revealed techniques. Accordingly, Patty and the rest of the crowd in the Rex remained fixed on the screen, notwithstanding the cinematic torture they’ve already suffered, as the main hypnotic induction sequence commences. Using the spiral as a hypnotic cue, combined with repetitive twilight language and flashing lights, the mother puts John into a deep trance. Meanwhile, our perspective flashes back and forth between that of the killer and of the audience inside the Rex, so that we’re subjected to the same frenzied hypnotic stimuli that we simultaneously see causing a metafictional audience to fall into varying degrees of trance. Presently, the entranced killer enters a movie theater himself, where he begins silently murdering the patrons one by one. The tension inside The Rex becomes unbearable, and at last Patty retreats into the bathroom, where, however, she now hears the mother’s voice telepathically beamed inside her head, signaling that her perspective is now his perspective, her eyes his eyes.
As the most sensitive member of the audience, the canary in the cinematic coal mine, Patty represents the soul of the viewer. The title, Anguish, refers to the torture of the viewer’s soul inherent to master manipulator cinema, crudely exemplified by the slasher subgenre. Trauma tears down psychic barriers, thereby rendering the victim exponentially more suggestible and thus ripe for reprogramming. The mother stands for the industry itself and the dark forces that preside over it, while the killer is the filmmaker who, having leased his own soul to break into the business, captures the souls of audiences and delivers them to his dark mistress. “Your eyes are my eyes,” says the mother inside the girl’s head. “Your hands are my hands”—a reminder that the master manipulator is actually the manipulated manipulator, like Cobb in Inception and like Nolan in real life.
The mother-bonding dynamic runs much deeper, though. As Horsley demonstrates, in his profound analysis of the topic, what the mother-bonded serial killer and the master manipulator filmmaker share in common above all is the desire to possess the mother’s body. But whereas the real Ed Gein and the fictional Buffalo Bill (from Silence of the Lambs) enact this desire on a physical and more or less literal level, the master manipulator seeks to recreate through celluloid images the imaginal space of the womb, and to escape the confines of the physical body into these dream worlds. The two analogous impulses—to reconstruct the mother’s physical body, on the one hand, and to recreate the womb psychically, on the other—can also be seen to overlap, for example, in the “transitioning” of Matrix directors Larry and Andy to Lana and Lilly, as Horsley discusses in his contribution to CES 3, “The Men Who Would Be Queens: Technosticism, Transgender & Transgression in the Plastic Arts,” and in other writings.
From Horsley’s perspective, master manipulator filmmaking reflects a pathological form of male identity-formation, which in any case occurs in opposition to the mother’s body. Hitchcock’s “Torture the women” formula “then represents a ‘breaking free from the mother’s body,’” which is precisely what John, in Anguish, is attempting to do: commanded by his mother to bring her “the eyes of the city,” he resists her psychic powers in an effort to forge an independent identity through self-authored violence.17 Similarly, the director, by jolting audiences with ultraviolence and other traumatic stimuli known to dissolve psychic barriers, endeavors to create a “shared space of experience” and to place himself “at the very center of it, like a priest, shaman, or king” (hence the name of the theater, “Rex” being Latin for “king”).
“Insofar as moviegoing recreates the formation of the (male) identity,” Horsley continues, “the director’s fantasies represented on the screen will be internalized and reenacted outside the theater, by impressionable viewers.”18 Once again, this is just what happens in the denouement of Anguish. A mother-addled gunman, obsessed with the meta-movie and incapable of distinguishing fantasy from reality, begins murdering people inside The Rex. At the climax, he’s holding Patty at gunpoint in front of the silver screen. After the police blow him away, she looks up at the meta-movie killer, whose scalpel pierces through the screen and into her real eye. Screaming in anguish as she flees the theater into the daylight, she soon realizes that there is no physical wound, that the pain was a psychosomatic effect of hypnosis. In the final scene, however, John reappears, in the flesh, at her bedside in the hospital, where she’s recovering from her psychic wound. “I want your eyes,” he says, “just like the others,” before jabbing a scalpel into her—and our—eye. We cut to black on her screams, whereupon the camera pulls back to reveal that her story too is a meta-movie, or a meta-meta-movie, being viewed by patrons of yet another theater, who file out as the credits roll. This final, fatal rupture of the fourth wall is meant to tear away the remnants of any boundary between the physical world and the psychic world. Or, more accurately, the purpose is to collapse the physical into the psychic, incepting the message that the movies can kill you anywhere, because you can’t run from your mind, any more than John could run from The Mommy.
Notes:
- Colonel Paul E. Vallely with Major Michael A. Aquino, “From PSYOP to MindWar: The Psychology of Victory” (Presidio, CA: 7th Psychological Operations Group, 1980), 5. Bold-face removed from source text. ↩︎
- O’Neill and Piepenbring, Chaos, 297–99. Emphases added. ↩︎
- Thanks to Millary for suggesting the Jung-Dulles angle and providing sources. ↩︎
- Christopher Knowles, Our Gods Wear Spandex: The Secret History of Comic Book Heroes (San Francisco: Weiser, 2007), 16. ↩︎
- Jeff Jensen, “’Watchmen’: A chat with director Zack Snyder,” Entertainment Weekly, Jul. 17, 2017, https://ew.com/article/2008/07/17/watchmen-chat-director-zack-snyder/. My emphasis. ↩︎
- Thanks to Millary for pointing out the wider cultural presence of the “divine child” archetype. ↩︎
- Jasun Horlsey, 16 Maps of Hell: The Unraveling of Hollywood Superculture (Auticulture, 2020), 199. ↩︎
- See Jamie White, “‘Naked, Drugged, 8 Gallons of Blood Weekly’: Britney Spears Details Systemic Abuse & Servitude in Cryptic Post,” Infowars, Mar. 7, 2022, https://web.archive.org/web/20220309084755/https://www.infowars.com/posts/naked-drugged-8-gallons-of-blood-weekly-britney-spears-details-systemic-abuse-servitude-in-cryptic-post/. ↩︎
- See Francesa Bacardi, “Harley Pasternak Threatens to ‘Institutionalize’ Kanye West: ‘Back to Zombieland,’” Page Six, Nov. 4, 2022, https://pagesix.com/2022/11/04/harley-pasternak-threatens-to-institutionalize-kanye-west/. ↩︎
- See “Did Kanye Expose Hollywood ‘Personal Trainer’ Harley Pasternak as an MK Handler?,” Vigilant Citizen, undated, https://vigilantcitizen.com/latestnews/did-kanye-expose-hollywood-personal-trainer-harley-pasternak-as-an-mk-handler/. ↩︎
- Martin Scorsese, interview by David Letterman, The David Letterman Show, Feb. 18, 1982, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qmLIqWCVGJ8. ↩︎
- Jasun Horsley, “The Moviegoer: Violence, Identity Formation, the Maternal Psyche, and Nihilistic Dream Worlds,” Cultural Engineering Studies, no. 1 (Jan. 2025), 58. ↩︎
- Horsley, “The Moviegoer,” 59, 61. ↩︎
- Carol J. Clover, Men, Women, and Chainsaws: Gender in the Modern Horror Film (London: BFI, 1992), 52, quoted in Horsley, “Moviegoer,” 59. ↩︎
- Horsley, “The Moviegoer,” 61. ↩︎
- Horsley, “The Moviegoer,” 61. ↩︎
- Jasun Horsley, “The Moviegoer,” 66. ↩︎
- Jasun Horsley, “The Moviegoer,” 66. Emphases in original ↩︎